Your spot to relax
Experience Jimmy Carter's Mexican Café
Nestled in the heart of San Diego at 3172 Fifth Ave, Jimmy Carter's Mexican Café beckons with authentic flavors and a welcoming ambiance. Known for its delectable breakfast, lunch, and dinner options, the café delights customers with standout dishes like shrimp taco salads and hearty quesadillas. Diners rave about the value, with many remarking on the friendly service and vibrant atmosphere. The pet-friendly outdoor patio is perfect for enjoying signature drinks like Guava Mimosas while people-watching. Whether you're a fan of traditional Mexican cuisine or seeking vegetarian options, this café creates an exceptional dining experience that keeps guests returning for more.
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Jimmy Carter's Mexican Café
Welcome to Jimmy Carter's Mexican Café, a beloved gem nestled in the vibrant heart of San Diego at 3172 Fifth Ave. With its inviting atmosphere, excellent service, and a menu that celebrates authentic Mexican cuisine, this café has rightfully earned its place as a neighborhood favorite.
From the moment you step through the doors, you are greeted by the delightful aroma of traditional dishes. The café boasts an impressive selection, including the much-praised shrimp taco salad and mouth-watering shredded chicken quesadilla. Each plate reflects a commitment to quality and authenticity, with every bite transporting you to the heart of Mexico.
What truly sets Jimmy Carter's Mexican Café apart is its welcoming atmosphere. With a lovely outdoor patio that is dog-friendly, patrons can enjoy their meals alfresco while soaking up the California sunshine. Customers rave about the fast and courteous service, highlighting the seamless dining experience. Friendly staff make every visit feel special, ensuring that your water and chips arrive within moments of being seated. Such attentiveness is noted in many reviews, with patrons praising the team for their quick service and cheerful demeanor.
For those adventurous enough to explore the drink menu, don't miss out on the popular Guava Mimosas. A refreshing addition to any meal, these cocktails enhance the relaxed and festive spirit of the café. Vegetarians are also well-catered for, with various customizable dishes available to satisfy all dietary preferences.
Whether you're looking for a casual lunch, a cozy dinner, or simply a spot to unwind with friends, Jimmy Carter's Mexican Café promises great value and an unforgettable experience. Diners return time and again, drawn by the enticing flavors and the sense of community that permeates the space. It’s a place where you can savor every bite, enjoy the company of loved ones, and feel like part of a family. Don’t just take our word for it—stop by, and you’ll see why this café is a cherished part of the San Diego dining scene.
For a delightful experience with every visit, call +1 619-295-2070 to make your reservation or simply drop by any day of the week to indulge in delicious Mexican cuisine.
Voices & Impressions
Guestbook
“ This is good food for the price. They have an outdoor patio section and it’s dog friendly. They also have Guava Mimosas. The value will get me to go back and try some of the other menu items. ”
“ Loved everything about this restaurant I highly recommend you stop in, you will not be disappointed ”
“ Had a very nice lunch at this long-standing neighborhood cafe. I've eaten here many times over the years and have never had a bad meal. The shrimp taco salad and a shredded chicken quesadilla were delicious and a great value. The menu has a great selection of authentic Mexican and other dishes. The sidewalk tables are also great for people-watching. They are open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and I recommend you give them a try. The house Margaritas are great here too! ”
“ I am Hispanic... having grown up with my mom who was an excellent cook making me great Mexican food since Iwas a small child. I literally grew up in authentic home made Mexican food as my primary diet. Years ago... back in 2015... a friend took me on a trip to San Diego for New Years. Since he had lived in San Diego before... and knowing that I love Mexican food... he suggested this place called Jimmy Carter's that was a favorite of his. I'm not gonna lie... when he mentioned the name of the restaurant... inside I shriveled at the thought of this restaurant. In my mind I thought... how good can a Mexican restaurant named "Jimmy Carter's" possibly be? I thought to myself it was likely gonna be an Americanized version of Mexican food. I agreed... with reluctance in my heart and mind... that I kept to myself. After all... I was his guest... and he was treating. Upon our arrival at breakfast time... I noticed that their table side salsa was truly outstanding and quite spicy. A win for me. I was starting to feel a little better about the restaurant. Craving some breakfast food... but still wanting something authentically Mexican... I went with the Chilaquiles (the red ones). Oh boy was I pleasantly surprised when they came to me... tasting very much like the ones my mom used to cook for me so many years ago!!! They were so tasty... with crispy tortilla chips drenched in their Norteña sauce, two fresh eggs (served to your liking) and sprinkled with cotija cheese. zthey were served with their delicious Spanish rice and tasty beans (black or pinto... your choice). WOW... JUST WOW!!! was truly impressed!!! I was now obsessed with this restaurant. I ended up asking to go back there one more time... before heading back home to L.A. I don't live anywhere near San Diego... but I now visit often... just to go to that restaurant!!! We've even made several trips to surrounding areas like Temecula and Fallbrook... and I happily make the trek to that restaurant just to eat... even if it means a few hours extra of travel time just for a meal. I have since turned every member of my family and several friends onto that place... and they ALL agree it's outstanding!!! Everything we've ever ordered on their menu is incredibly delicious!!! I also highly recommend the Barburrito (please smother this in their Norteña sauce) & the Nuevo Leon Enchiladas from their breakfast menu... but honestly... nothing we've ever ordered from there was ever a mistake!!! If you haven't tried them... I highly suggest you do!!! You're welcome!!! ”
“ I had the most spectacular lunch at this Mexican restaurant here in San Diego. The taco salad was so delicious. The service was very friendly and the overall ambiance of this place is exceptional. I highly recommend trying this place if you are here in San Diego for whatever reason ”